Last year I had to cut down a red maple tree. I was able to save three of its offspring.

One is ~2' tall and I moved it from where it volunteered behind a bush to the middle of the yard.

Another is ~8" tall and spent most of last year in a pot. Buried the pot in the ground in early fall.

The last one is a pure untouched volunteer, ~6" tall growing right up against the stump of the old tree.

How can I tell if these saplings survived the winter?

I see very small buds on all of them. Should these buds be hard or soft?

What other signs indicate a healthy, young red maple sapling?

  • FWIW two years later and all three candidates are doing fine. One is darn near 9' tall, the other a bit over 6', and the stump one is over waist high. She doesn't get as much sun.
    – Freiheit
    Jul 11, 2016 at 12:44

1 Answer 1


If you can pull a bud apart and it is still green inside, then things are looking good. If the buds are dry and brittle and don't show any life inside, then you may have a dead sapling. On the saplings that have branches, if the buds are not looking good, you can gently scrape a bit of bark off of the branch and look for a green layer. In any case, since it will soon be spring, you can always wait a few weeks and see which ones begin to leaf out, and that will be a definitive answer about which are healthy and survived the winter.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.