9

I was going to ask this as an aside in this question, but I remembered that there are no asides in StackExchange.

Say I've done this again:

I go out and I plant two rows of beets, two rows of turnips, two rows of radishes and two rows of carrots.

Given beets, carrots and radishes like 18 inches between rows and turnips like 24 inches between rows. How close do I plant the first row of turnips to the last row of beets and how close do I plant the last row of turnips to the first row of radishes?

7

"How to Grow More Vegetables" by John Jeavons, deals with exactly this question. Page 160, "Companion Planting; In Space" -- he's talking about companion planting corn and beets intermingled in a bed, but the same logic applies to your question:

... One way to determine the spacing for different plants grown together is to add their spacing together and divide by 2. If you grow corn and beets together, add 15 inches and 4 inches for a total of 9 inches. Divide by 2 and you get a per-plant spacing of 9 1/2 inches. The beets, then, would be 9 1/2 inches from each corn plant and vice versa.

This is followed by a diagram showing how each corn plant gets the necessary 15" diameter growing space, and each beet gets its necessary 4" diameter space.

  • Is it specifically talking about the row spacing on a given seed packet or is there some chart in the book? – Peter Turner Jun 28 '11 at 16:57
  • The references to specific spacing in the quote above are based on a chart in the book, but the principle applies to what you're planting with whatever arbitrary spacing you use. E.g. if the packet says to use 12" spacing, then the plant wants a 12" diameter area to grow in; use that in the formula above. – bstpierre Jun 28 '11 at 17:01
5

No experience here, just some simple thinking and math. I would halve the two distances and add them then use that number. Think about the plant needing half of the row spacing on each side. So if it needs 12" of space then it needs 6" on each side. If another plant needs 18" of space then it needs 9" on each side. Thus if you plant the 12" and the 18" in neighboring rows I would use at least 15" of space between them.

  • That might be the answer, but it might be that turnips actually need the full 18 inches. – Peter Turner Jun 24 '11 at 18:21
  • @Peter, but then wouldn't two rows of turnips interfere with each other? – wax eagle Jun 24 '11 at 18:55
  • 1
    Yeah, they do interfere with each other a little bit even with 24 inches. I did do what you suggested, leaving 21 inches between carrots and turnips and turnips and radishes. (I wrote the wrong thing above, 24 inches for turnips). Turnips get taller quicker than carrots, so they've pretty well overshadowed the my carrots now in the afternoon, probably not a problem, but they'd have a bit more sunlight with 3 more inches, as would anything planted a set number of inches away. – Peter Turner Jun 24 '11 at 19:14

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.