I’m in the Caribbean, and someone’s selling a 6-ft potted tree that seller identifies as “pine”. I’m including pictures.

Can anyone identify this tree? I only have these pictures.

Can this remain in the pot? The seller tells me it grew in the pot. I have an apartment, so it can’t grow over 6-ft.

I also have a terrace without a roof, so it would receive tons of sun if I move it up there.

enter image description here enter image description here

1 Answer 1


That looks like either a Norfolk Island Pine (Auracaria heterophylla) or a Cook Pine (Araucaria columnaris). It is not a pine, but a conifer from either Norfolk Island or New Caledonia in the Pacific. Both trees make very pretty landscape trees; unfortunately, the one pictured appears to have been topped, although I could very well be wrong about that. In the wild, both species tend to be slow growing, but can grow quite tall (150–200 feet). Keeping it in a pot should have dwarfed it a little, but it is already six-feet high, so not really suitable for your apartment...

  • Norfolk Pines are popular house plants in the US because they like to grow in filtered sunlight or light shade, and can live in the low light intensity of most houses. Humidity and heated houses in the winter are issues (the plant tends to be very fussy), so I'm guessing that many die a year or two after purchase.
  • Cook Pines are popular street trees in the tropical regions of the world. The tallest is about 150 feet high, living in a park in Brazil. They like full sun and a somewhat sheltered position (if in pots).

When young, both species look nearly identical, so it will be hard to tell them apart. It's important to know which tree it is, because Norfolk Island Pines do not like direct sun or very warm temperatures, while Cook Pines love full sun and do well in Hawaii and other tropical areas.

If the tree you pictured has always grown in its pot in full sun, then it's almost certainly a Cook Pine. In that case, it would grow just fine on your terrace, provided that the area is sheltered from strong winds.

  • I agree a Cook Pine.
    – GardenGems
    Commented Dec 11, 2019 at 1:39
  • Thanks. Would a close-up picture help clear up any difference between the Norfolk Island Pine and Cook Pine?
    – rbhat
    Commented Dec 11, 2019 at 3:22
  • In this case, a closeup wouldn't help much because the trees don't start to look different until they're about 25 ft tall - Cook Pines are rather columnar while Norfolk Island Pines are pyramidal. Cook pines tend to lean at an 8 degree angle towards the Equator. If the tree you're interested leans like that (and it looks like it does), then you have a Cook pine. Here's an interesting link (with photos): sciencealert.com/…
    – Jurp
    Commented Dec 11, 2019 at 12:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.