I have a large 54" (1.37 m) diameter cottonwood tree that is 16 feet (5 m) away from where a storm sewer is to be installed. I am sure roots will be cut, but will this tree survive? If the chances are not good, how long would it take to show signs of dying?

  • Pictures please and where is tree located? – kevinskio Aug 31 '18 at 19:27
  • I am in Palatine Ill – David Soemo Aug 31 '18 at 19:32
  • I would appreciate any info you can give me – David Soemo Aug 31 '18 at 19:33

Sounds like a very nice tree and worth some consideration. Mark off on the ground where you think your lot line is. Then pace off the distance from the base of the tree to the drip line (extreme-most branches twigs). That gives you the radius of the likely root circle. Now figure what portion of the circle will be affected and express it in percent. Now we have numbers.

Call the local forestry department or works department in charge of the sewer work and tell them about your tree and how it is likely to be affected. The forestry people are really anxious to work with you to minimize the effect on local valuable trees. They have to show due diligence and will appreciate your call. It shows you are interested. Keep a note of your contact efforts.

They will probably send someone to talk to you. Ask them what they can do to minimize the effect on the tree and ask their advice on remedial measures when the roots are removed. Get them to mark exactly where they think the lot line is with fluorescent marker so the guys on the backhoe can see it even through a dirty window. The city has full control over their side. Your roots if any on their side have "escaped" your property. The installation crew may be able to narrow the trench where they go past your tree, minimizing root damage (in particular there are various sizes of digging bucket. They don't have to use a 3 foot bucket to bury a one foot pipe).

16 feet is a nice good distance. Please report back what portion of the root area will be affected. If you need help with calcs just say so. After the work it will be about a year before you see any effect in the tree, since we are going into the fall. Good luck.

  • This is good stuff, Colin. Very sensible! Asking for mitigation to save a huge cotonwood tree is in their best interest. If that tree gets too many roots cut (that could be up to a third to half the roots before seeing major damage) it will make your tree a 'widow maker'. They know tree roots don't observe property lines and they most certainly can be liable for damage and death by cutting tree roots. – stormy Aug 31 '18 at 22:09

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.