4

I have use Miracle Grow for years. I am hearing nowadays that Miracle Grow might be is harmful.

I plant in ground. I have a garden 60 feet by 90 feet. I have grown lovely tomatoes and other items. I have sand for soil. Grass does not grow well. I get weeds that's it. I miracle grow every two weeks roughly. I mix it per the container. However I do not give it as the container says.. One gallon per a tomato plant.. I water probably 8 to 10 plants with 2 gallons.

How bad is it really?

I am starting a compost this year but it will not be ready. And I plan on in the fall mixing in bunny poo. This area had been a garden for over 40 years.

Any suggestions?

  • 2
    What have you heard about its being harmful - is it because of 'salts'? – Bamboo Jun 12 '18 at 19:57
  • 1
    Fertilizer has been willy nilly dumped into the same category as pesticide and ALL chemicals. Compost is not will never be fertilizer. Compost might have a bit and needs to be taken into consideration for your fertilizer PROGRAM. But compost is not fertilizer nor is it a soil replacement. Great stuff but not fertilizer even though it might have bits of fertilizer. You will not know unless you take a COMPOST sample test. I've already tested composts that are decomposed. I would never use compost that is raw. I always cut directions at least by half good for you! – stormy Jun 12 '18 at 22:41
  • Lots of No Till, No Fertilizer advocates insist fertilizer ruins the soil. I am sorry but there is no truth to that at all. Ugh, this is my little ditty about fertilizer; Less is Best, More is Death and None is Dumb...does that make sense to you? Once organic material is digested there is no substantial Nitrogen, nor Phosphorus nor Potassium to be had in that compost. What decomposed organic matter is made for are the soil macro and micro organisms. They eat this material only Decomposers use up the Nitrogen first for their energy. This makes wonderful soil, it is the only way to ammend – stormy Jun 12 '18 at 22:47
  • As long as you aren't feeding your bunnies meat products, make sure you decompose first in your compost pile. Do not use raw bunny pellets, okay? You can purchase 'bales' of decomposed organic matter. Make sure it is decomposed. Sadly you'll find sticks and recognizable chunks but it will be far better than non decomposed unusable organic matter. Like straw, chips...? – stormy Jun 12 '18 at 22:51
  • 1
    I am guessing someone here is either selling fertilizer or having huge interests in it, like say, working for lobby. My advice is Do not use agro-chemistry fertilizer. Too much money in the game - makes people crazy. There is plenty of other great stuff to amend your mother earth. – J. Chomel Jun 13 '18 at 6:22
5

If you have sand for soil, unless you live in a desert, it's very possibly (but not definitely) acidic and poor in nutrients. Desert soils are often sandy and alkaline, with caliche underneath. Although Miracle Gro can add needed fertilizer and minerals, it should be noted that some nitrogen fertilizers may contribute to soil acidification (acidification can make your soil even more sandy, so I've read). I don't know if your kind of Miracle Gro contributes to soil acidification, but fertilizers generally are sometimes stereotyped as leading to soil acidification over time (although only some of them do that); if soil gets too acidic, that could cause problems (see further below). This may be why some might think it could be bad to use for your purposes.

Fortunately, if your soil is too acidic, you can always add something alkaline to it, like lime, wood ash, rockdust, etc. which should help to level out the pH. Things high in calcium tend to be alkaline. You should not assume that your soil is acidic, however. Many people like to think you should always get a soil test in such situations, so as to avoid the possibility of making your soil more problematic than it was to start with (and to avoid unnecessary labor/time/costs due to error), and so you can add exactly what you need and nothing else. I'm not going to say you should always do that (since I kind of like to wing it sometimes, and learn what works for my soil by experimentation and intuition—and it's often less expensive), but there are enough people who will disagree with my methodology that maybe you would be one of them if you knew more about the situation. So, I recommend a soil test if you can get one.

If you can't get a soil test, don't give up hope, but so as not to raise ire from other-minded people, I'm not going to go on about how to deal with that situation (although it is possible). With traditional methods, it takes a lot less time to raise soil pH than to lower it (so, be very careful any time you decide to try to raise the soil pH—or any time you use something with high levels of calcium in it, like lime, wood ash, rockdust, etc.)

Having a soil pH that is too acidic or too alkaline can cause nutrient deficiencies and toxicities (due to nutrients being either too available or not available enough—whether or not the nutrients are there). This can result in stunted plants, stippled foliage, yellow foliage, and other stuff.

There are many other reasons why some people might think that adding Miracle Gro is a bad idea (and no, I'm not saying it's a bad idea by listing the reasons people sometimes have; I'm seeking to help you understand why people say what they say; I'm not trying to make you anti-Miracle Gro). I'll list some reasons that I've heard.

  • It's not approved for organic gardening. There are lots of organic gardeners out there. It contains synthetic fertilizer salts.
  • There are a lot of people who are against using phosphorus, whether because they think the soil always already has enough (whether or not it's available), or whether they think the phosphorus industry is unethical or otherwise harmful. Miracle Gro tends to contain appreciable levels of phosphorus (but not high levels compared to other fertilizers). Another reason people are against water-soluble phosphorus is that it can leach into the ground water. Some may assume that all phosphorus is water soluble, but this is not true. However, Miracle Gro tends to be entirely water soluble.
  • It's quick-release. Some people don't believe in using quick-release fertilizers for some reason—probably because it doesn't happen in nature too much). I can appreciate this rationale at least where it pertains to acclimatization (where people are trying to breed plants that are not reliant on such fertilizers, as Joseph Lofthouse does with landraces—he raises plants without fertilizer and *cides—not particularly just quick-release).
  • Using too much Miracle Gro may result in 'salty' soil. Salty doesn't refer specifically to sodium, by the way. A salt is a mineral or element that is bound to an acid. For instance, magnesium malate is a salt that people use for supplementing magnesium in humans (malate comes from malic acid, and magnesium is the mineral). Some people worry a lot about using too many fertilizer salts (since if soil is too salty, it is said to cause issues for plants).
  • It's easy to burn plants with Miracle Gro. Some people don't like to risk burning plants. But, if you follow the directions, you shouldn't normally burn any plants (although it is possible). Be sure to research the salt index. Different fertilizer salts have different indexes. The higher the index, the greater the likelihood of plants being burned. I've personally found it easy to burn indoor pre-transplant vegetables with 24-8-16 Miracle Gro, but I don't think I've ever burned an outdoor plant or a houseplant with it (it works great for houseplants, in my experience). They make kinds that are more suited for vegetables, and I've used one for tomatoes (but it's not my favorite for pre-transplant tomatoes; I haven't tried it outdoors).
  • I don't know all of the Miracle Gro products do, but some fertilizers kill some soil microbes, and a lot of people probably assume that Miracle Gro does by default. I know calcium nitrate, and potassium chloride, are said to kill soil microbes. I don't know about other fertilizer salts (other than at least some nitrates), however, and I don't know if Miracle Gro contains nitrates or potassium chloride (but it's a good possibility). Edit: My 24-8-16 All Purpose Plant Food (years old) contains potassium chloride, but no nitrates. Some people think urea kills soil life, but I haven't been able to verify whether this is true or false; it would seem to stimulate it if anything, from what I know about it.
  • Some may think it's unhealthy. This may in some cases be because of reactions they or others have to certain fertilizer ingredients. Or, they may worry about fluoride, plthalates, lead, and other stuff, whether or not they're in Miracle Gro (they are in some fertilizers).

Also, realize that desert soils may be high in water soluble salts already (although in a 40-year-old garden I'm more doubtful of that); so, if you do have alkaline, sandy soil, you'd potentially have to worry about the salts in your fertilizer, even if the acidification isn't a concern. You'd probably want a soil test to find what, if anything, you need.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.