3

I was reading up a few weeks ago on fertilizing and someone, somewhere said that grinding down egg shells would be a good idea to increase calcium in the soil.

Now this made me save some egg shells and peanut casings. My question is, without grinding them down, would it be a good idea to mix it into the soil when planting plants like peppers for example? Would the same apply for, for example, banana peals?

The reason I ask this is because my brother said he wouldn't do it since potting soil already has an over abundance of nutrients and it would likely damage the plants.

  • It sounds like you are talking about composting in a pot with a growing plant. Could be a possible recipe for insects, mold etc. Also, how do you determine the NPK of a banana peel? I think there are easier/less risky ways to feed your plants. – Tim Nevins Jan 15 '18 at 14:17
4

I doubt that eggshells well make any difference to your potting mix. I used to see these years later in the compost heap still intact unless it's been quite acidic.

As for organic matter such as banana peels they will slowly decompose in the mix releasing nutrients. Organic fertilisers like this don't usually harm plants unlike inorganic fertilisers which can cause nutrient burn.

  • So in short, it might be a good idea to include banana peals for nutrients, perhaps the peanut shells for drainage but the egg shells won't do anything, correct? – Tikkes Jan 16 '18 at 10:28
  • I didn't say it was a good idea :) Your potting mix should already have enough nutrient to get things started, and the slow decomposition of these things may not provide enough nutrient to keep going. I just don't see much harm in it, and it might provide enough material for things like earthworms to survive in your pots. – Graham Chiu Jan 16 '18 at 20:26
0

If you take your eggshells, & soak them in a bowl of vinegar, it will begin the process of breaking them down a lot faster, ... as the vinegar will react to the calcium in the shell, ... & it will look as if it is boiling the shell bits, ... Ever do any pickled eggs? This does the same thing, by making the shells rubbery, ...lol, ...

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.