I am in Zone 9b and have 3 raised beds that I want to use during the winter season to produce something rather than leaving them idle (let me know if that is a good thing). Should I grow vegetables and if so which one's would be best? Would root vegetables like carrots, beet, ginger germinate and grow in this weather? How about vegetables like kale, broccoli, cauliflower, cabbage? If none of these are an option, should I just put fava beans so that I can harvest and use those to enrich my compost?

  • 2
    cover crops for 1 thing Dec 1, 2016 at 22:39
  • 1
    @blackthumb would you put cover crop in all 3 raised beds and skip growing veggies in winter? Looking for your experience
    – JStorage
    Dec 2, 2016 at 0:25
  • grow a food cover crop like Portulaca oleracea in one, since it grows from root division, and will always be there. in another maybe some "wild lettuce", and clover. I'm not familiar with everything that could be good ground cover, so some people might be able to advise you on what to grow. also watch this video: youtube.com/watch?v=Hnq31mynSbk Dec 2, 2016 at 4:28

2 Answers 2


Your zone is wonderful for growing anything...except for plants that hate periods of high heat. If you are able to ventilate and/or semi shade your garden you should be able to grow anything all year. Pretty much. Plants you will have difficulty with are fast to bolt crops, such as broccoli, cauliflower, spinach, mustards. Have you tried growing any crops in this zone? For your winter you should be able to grow peas, fennel, tomatoes, potatoes, the fast to bolt crops I just mentioned as long as the temperatures stay regular. Bolting is caused by drastic temperature change. Signalling the plant that it better reproduce because the environment has become unpredictable. I think this is the best time to grow kale and your brassicas. I haven't had the luxury to garden in your zone, lucky you. If you germinate your seed inside and then allow them to become starts to plant in your garden, you have to ACCLIMATE your starts before you plant. Have you had a soil test? pH is important to know to be able to group the plants you want to grow with other plants with similar needs...leafy/vegetative crops versus root crops versus fruit/reproductive crops. Potatoes need very acidic soil versus others needing a more neutral pH.

Here is a list of stuff you should get excited about; Vegetables...all of these should do just fine for your 'winter'...man, what was I thinking to move to ZONE 1B???? Asparagus needs 3 years before harvesting, but worth it. I actually have a crop surviving!!

Green onions Onions Asparagus Arugula Basil (do you have periodic frosts during winter)? Beets Bok Choy Broccoli Cabbage Carrots Cauliflower Corn Cucumbers (periodic frosts) Garlic Green Beans (periodic frosts) Leeks Onions Peppers (periodic frosts) Potatoes (don't worry about periodic frosts) Salad Mix Spinach (periodic frosts) Sweet Potatoes (periodic frosts) Tomatoes (periodic frosts) Winter Squash (periodic frosts) Zucchini (periodic frosts)

Periodic frosts could damage these plants. Periodic frosts are a microclimate thing. If your garden shows periodic frosts, do not plant these. Please make sure you plant starts if you have cold nights below 40 degrees F. Don't rely on germinating seed in the garden.

If you do have periodic frosts/freezes or temperatures that sometimes dip below 50 degrees F, go get some ROW CLOTH. This stuff IS A PLANT SAVER. Cheap, easy to cover your crops with and protects against huge temperature changes. Not only does it protect against temperature changes, it protects your brassicas from the cabbage fly/moth/larvae until they are able to be large enough to resist and/or the season for this insect is past. Also helps with flea beetle, allows rain water to get in, sun to get in, protects from wind damage and direct sun...

Hope this helps, please send more questions if necessary!!

  • I do get periodic frosts and hence the choices are quite limited.
    – JStorage
    Dec 1, 2016 at 23:26
  • What is a 'frost' like to you and your clime? Have you grown vegetables here? Frosts are not a deal breaker for vegey gardens. I know because I have these FREEZES even in July and August!! Arggghhh. Row cloth will protect your plants by raising the ambient temperature 10-20 degrees. If I didn't have row cloth I'd have had zip for crops!! We will have a heated greenhouse this next spring but row cloth is a crop saver!!
    – stormy
    Dec 1, 2016 at 23:48
  • 1
    Good idea reg. row cloth. Temp goes down to 30's and 40's so crops need protection. I grow veggies all other seasons. In winter it has been idle and last year I put cover crop. This year I want to make it productive and hence the question.
    – JStorage
    Dec 2, 2016 at 0:24

I'm south of you so my climate is colder but the Asian greens I planted for winter all bolted.

The only thing that did well were the faba beans. The last winter was mild so they just kept growing, and I had pretty white flowers at the end of winter. I've also had a large harvest of broad beans from them though the wind took out many as I didn't have enough stakes to support them all, and they get pretty tall. I'm keeping some uneaten so I can plant again in autumn.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.