6

A 12" square catch basin collects water from my driveway and transports it under the lawn to adjacent stream about 150 ft away via 4" corrugated buried pipe. They used corrugated covered w/stone (vs pvc) (20 yrs ago) so as to also collect surface water from the poor-drainage yard. The drain pipe is down to a trickle due to tree roots that infiltrated the 4" pipe. In a downpour the basin overflows. In the past (2X) it was cleared by a roto rooter type power auger. This time it can't get through and they are suggesting that a hi-pressure jetter could do the trick (maybe) at a cost of $600-800. A lot of money but much less than excavating, digging up & replacing the 150 ft pipe. Does the jetter stand a a chance or am I throwing money away? It could also possibly damage the existing pipe but that might not matter if the pipe needs to be replaced anyway. Would appreciate any comments and perhaps alternate approaches to this problem. Thank you.

  • 1
    what type of tree are you talking about? how old is this tree? Where do you live...what have your neighbors done in the past with similar trees? I am glad that you aren't thinking of ripping out the tree...do you have invoices where the company explains to you what they think is necessary? – stormy Apr 4 '16 at 20:04
  • Thank you, the tree is a maple, about 15 years old, I believe the roots blocking the drain are around 1/4",1/2 max diameter. We are in southeast PA, a suburb of Philly. Don't want to remove the tree. No invoice, just a verbal "we should be able to do this, if not with 5,000 or 10,000 psi hose (jetter) then with a similar device that also has a rotating cutter-type attachment". – Extonite Apr 4 '16 at 23:12
4

Listen, if roots are infiltrating, you least expensive solution is to dig it out, retrench, and put in a new drain. You may also wish to trim back the roots, and make a wider trench with heavier gravel at the point where the tree is infiltrating to slow it down.

Why is this cheaper? Because it's going to happen again and again, and you are going to be forced to replace it again anyway.

If the French drain is 20 year old anyway, it's probably due for replacement here or there along the line.

Use PVC where it's being infiltrated, and make it a longer than apparently needed because eventually the roots are going to find the ends of the PVC.

Do yourself a favor and save money in the long run. Trying to save money today is going to cost you even more later, and maybe even have to spend it right away if the jetter doesn't do the trick. If it does the trick you'll be facing the problem again next year.

| improve this answer | |
  • This is a great comment Escoce! To dig and retrench and possibly screen to prevent roots from growing in that direction would be your best bet. Please send some pictures. Don't think 150 needs to be redone... Use galvanized metal roofing to stop the roots from growing toward the pipes. Chopping roots in a small section of the circle of roots will not hurt your tree. If you water this tree a few times a year it won't go 'looking' for water and access your pipes. Sketch out the tree, its drip line, proximity to the pipes, direction of the pipes, sounds like this is a french drain, yes? – stormy Apr 5 '16 at 18:17

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.