I am currently living in the California Bay Area, a subtropic region. I grow quite a few tropical trees in my backyard. This winter has been the first subtropic winter that these trees have ever experienced. Typically, the nights here were 40-50 fahrenheit and days were 70 fahrenheit. There was only one night that dropped to 39 fahrenheit. I've only been watering my trees sparingly once a week because I heard trees don't need much water in the winter. None of my tropical trees appear healthy now, so I would like to assess whether they have survived the cold weather or not. Are they dead or not?

This is my Wax Apple. In the summer, it branched vigorously and had tons of huge leaves, bigger than the size of a human hand. It has dropped nearly every leaf. Also, the small outer branches have blackened. The inner bigger trunk is still tan colored. (I strung up a lot of the branches because during one storm the winds bent the branches straight down).

enter image description here

This is my Century Guava. It hasn't lost many leaves. However, they've become a pale yellow-green color and then eventually purple. Its branches appear unchanged - they have a flaky skin as most tropical guava have. (I know mulch isn't supposed to touch the trunk. During the dry times, I keep the mulch as close to, but not touching, the trunk).

enter image description here

Update on April 25, 2015

The wax apple is presumed dead. All leaves were lost during the winter. All my other tropical trees have came back from hibernation except the wax apple. I cut into its trunk to test for any green color. Nope. It was dried to the bone. Farewell, my good friend. I will need to start from ground zero again...

  • 2
    Patience is a virtue when assessing whether a plant will recover. Many a plant looks dead but the roots survive and it will regrow if given time.
    – kevinskio
    Feb 1, 2015 at 23:00
  • 1
    You've got a D3 or D4 drought in that area: droughtmonitor.unl.edu You might consider upping the watering schedule for your small plants a bit. Besides that, it's winter. You have leaves and buds, have patience. Feb 2, 2015 at 15:47

1 Answer 1


Neither of the two plants pictured appears dead - there may be some killing back of top branches or woody parts in the first due to cold weather, but there are still green leaves present at the base, so the plant is not dead. The second one still looks very much alive, despite the leaf colour change - many plants have leaves which redden when the weather is cold, or at least, cold for them. A dead plant will have no living leaves, and the woody parts may change colour, but often, plants that look like this are not actually dead, and as the growing season advances, start producing growth.

  • If a tropical tree loses all its leaves, does it mean that it is dead? I have another outdoor Custard Apple (Annona Squamosa) that has no more green leaves. It's just hanging on to a bunch of blackened leaves.
    – JoJo
    Feb 7, 2015 at 21:15
  • No, not necessarily - if you're too impatient to wait and see if it grows when spring arrives, you can just peel back a bit of the surface, or skin, of the bark on the woody parts with a fingernail - if its dry and brown inside, its dead - but only on that part, not necessarily completely dead.
    – Bamboo
    Feb 7, 2015 at 21:45

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.