I have seen the thread on an organic way to repel slugs. However, usually I only see snails in my area. Will the techniques in the answer there work on snails too? Also,

By the way, I've never seen a slug in my life here in Hong Kong. Are slugs/snails location specific?

  • Yes they are location specific. Rarely seen in our Texas garden and then they are tiny thing arhat don't do any noticeable damage (we do get turritella snails though). Walking in North Wales yesterday, MrsWinwaed was impressed by the novelty of a large black one we saw crossing the path. The sort all the UK gardeners here would quickly kill if they saw it. Slugs really need damp conditions, so the UK, Pacific Northwest are excellent places, Hong Kong; drier parts of Texas; deserts are poor places to find them.
    – winwaed
    Commented Aug 9, 2011 at 8:39

2 Answers 2


Yes, the same methods "should" work on both of them, slugs and snails belong to the same taxonomic class:

  • Gastropods

    The Gastropoda or gastropods, more commonly known as snails and slugs. are a large taxonomic class within the Mollusca. The class Gastropoda includes snails and slugs of all kinds and all sizes from microscopic to quite large. There are huge numbers of sea snails and sea slugs, as well as freshwater snails and freshwater limpets, and land snails and land slugs.

  • Snail

    Snail is a common name for almost all members of the molluscan class Gastropoda that have coiled shells in the adult stage. When the word is used in a general sense, it includes sea snails, land snails and freshwater snails. Otherwise snail-like creatures that lack a shell (or have only a very small one) are called slugs.

  • Slug

    Slug is a common name that is normally applied to any gastropod mollusk that lacks a shell, has a very reduced shell, or has a small internal shell. This is in contrast to the common name snail, which is applied to gastropods that have coiled shells that are big enough to retract into.

  • Snail -> Slug

    Gastropod species which lack a conspicuous shell are commonly called slugs rather than snails, although, other than having a reduced shell or no shell at all, there are really no appreciable differences between a slug and a snail except in habitat and behavior.

I'm currently using the "beer trap" method in my (newish) Hosta garden, but so far with no desirable results. I must admit I'm starting to think it might not be slugs/snails, even though they are "generally" considered the number 1 pest problem where Hostas are concerned. Instead I'm now thinking the unwanted diner might be bigger and covered in fur...

A friend highly recommended I try "Diatomaceous Earth" as a way to protect plants from slugs/snails. So far I haven't tried it, but if I switch back to thinking it's slugs/snails eating my Hostas I may very well give it a try.

Other "organic" slug/snail control options I might try:

  • Coffee grounds spread around the plants.

  • Crushed egg shells spread around the plants.

  • Natural predators, either by attracting them into the garden or by physically bringing them in.

  • Iron phosphate baits, but I've heard "good" & "bad" things about those traps (even though they're marketed as an "organic" option), therefore I would need to research further before deciding if I would use them in my garden.

Additionally, I think this article, "Slugs and Snails" from University of Missouri Extension is worth a read.

Q. Is slug/snail location specific?

I honestly don't know for certain, but I thought both slugs and snails were found pretty much all over the world.


In addition to the organic slug-repellents already mentioned, I would strongly recommend a grow tunnel (either thick-mesh or micro-mesh) which, if carefully placed, provides a barrier that is almost 100% effective. See answer and comments here Micro-mesh Grow Tunnel

Thick-mesh Grow Tunnel

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.