My lawn is old and in desperate need of over-seeding. Many people in my area (Denver, Colorado) say to do it in the Fall. My thinking is that in the Fall the lawn areas are very dry and that aerating the hard, predominantly clay soil will be almost impossible. Also, the trees are full of leaves in the Fall and the lawn gets very little sun. Finally, the conditions are not very good for growing anything due to the approaching Winter.

These arguments suggest early Spring is the best time. What do you think?

  • I guess you meant Denver, Colorado. If not, please add the correct location. Thanks.
    – Niall C.
    Nov 11, 2014 at 18:19

1 Answer 1


You would not want to overseed right now in Denver as there would not be enough time for the seeds to germinate and the new grass establish. But seeding early enough in the fall gives the grass a head start at a time when many broad leaf weeds and crabgrass, which would normally compete with grass for resources, are going dormant or dying. Come spring, the established grass "seedlings" will have a jump on the weeds, which will just be sprouting as the soil warms up. The grass will grow faster and compete with the weeds more effectively than it would if you seeded in the spring. The fall planted turf will be denser come spring, so it will also tend to shade out and prevent some weeds from germinating in the first place - something that grass seed spread in the spring wouldn't do.

That said, seeding in the spring will still improve turf density nicely, and is advisable if you couldn't do it in the fall.

As for aerating, don't worry about the dry,hard clay soil - that's what good aerators are for. A commercial plug aerator is designed to punch tubes into and remove plugs from compacted (hard) soil. If you're planning to grow grass, you'll probably want to water it anyway, and it is advisable to soak soil prior to aerating for good plug extraction.

On a final note, it would be great to take this opporunity to add compost. The compost will improve your soil in a number of ways, and will help your new grass germinate and grow. That link also has decent info on aerating in general.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.