How do you prune/pinch/wire a Cryptomeria japonica to shape it into the formal upright "chokkan" style, like this or this? Whenever I've tried this with other evergreen species, I've never been able to get the foliage to separate into those distinctive "clumps".

enter image description here

Edit: Added picture. It's actually a "Birodo" dwarf variety that I bought at a local nursery. It's only about 6" tall and not much to look at. I have it in a small planter with a couple of other dwarf species (a maple and holly) that will be wintering together. Come spring, I'll relocate it to its own planter and let it get bigger before I start any work on it.

  • That part is usually accomplished by pruning. Can you post a picture of what you have now? I haven't done it for a long time, but I can give you some basic guidelines to follow. What tools/materials do you have? – J. Musser Sep 24 '14 at 20:31
  • Yes, please send a picture! And make sure that every time you prune you clean your pruners with alcohol and sharpen if you've been using them for any other plant. How long have you been doing bonsai? How long have you had this plant? Did you plant it or did it come that way from the nursery? – stormy Sep 25 '14 at 21:36
  • @stormy people don't generally use bonsai pruners for anything but their bonsai. Cleaning and sharpening when necessary is a must. – J. Musser Sep 25 '14 at 21:45
  • For big bonsai purists I am sure that is correct. A big bummer to learn the hard way on a bonsai!! Just thought I'd throw that in so they don't have to go through the same thing...not many people (gosh, even people that earn their living through nurseries) KNOW to do cleaning and sharpening in-between plants. – stormy Sep 25 '14 at 21:50
  • @J.Musser, Picture added. I have some good sharp pruning shears, wire, rope and weights. Although I've stopped using wire because I've found it's too easy to scar the plant, so I've been relying on tie-downs to shape branches. – Cerin Sep 26 '14 at 13:44

Here's what the Sunset's Bonsai handbook says about the chokan style:

Picture a plant with a perfectly straight, virtually cylindrical trunk that tapers gradually as it rises vertically from the soil, and you are likely visualizing a Formal Upright. The trunk base splays outward just enough to indicate that radiating roots give good support. An example in nature is the majestic tree that stands alone in a field or lawn.

The lowest and longest branch should appear about a third of the way up the trunk, and perhaps angle slightly toward the front of the plant. The next branch as you proceed upward should be a bit smaller and extend toward the opposite side of the bonsai, angling slightly forward. The third branch will be smaller yet, extending toward the back of the plant.

This ascending spiral pattern repeats as you progress up the trunk to the apex, the branches getting smaller and more closely spaced as they approach the tp. A finished Formal Upright specimen will be nearly cone shaped.

Ordinarily, large branches that point toward the front of the plant are undesirable because they obscure the structure rather than enhance it, but small branches in the in the upper third of the plant may project forward slightly if they fit the overall design pattern. To determine which branches to keep, remember that branches on opposite sides of the trunk should not be at the same level, and no branch should be directly above another one.

So you need to first select and keep the permanent branches, pruning out the others. This is the first step toward proper shaping. After that, you will have to pinch out new growth on the branches, to encourage bushiness, and keep them contained. This is also how you get the "clumpy" look you are looking for. Don't let the branches grow together. You also want to pinch at a few different levels, so you don't end up with a mini topiary. Perform this at any time, as needed throughout the growing season.

For wiring, make sure wires are in place in winter, so that they are in place during the next seasons growth. Only wire ripened wood. Wire only if you need to redirect the direction some of the growth is pointing. You may not need to wire all the branches, if some are in naturally good spots. On areas with thin bark, wrap with raffia before applying wire. I use aluminum wire, but many folks use copper.

Some branches, if they only need to be brought down, can be weighted instead of wiring. Use properly heavy bonsai weights. If a branch is too stiff to wire, you can tie it down to the container, so that it grows where it is needed. If one branch is higher than another, which is too low, you can protect the stems with raffia, and tie the stems together.

  • What a great answer! Bonsai is the absolute ultimate omnipotent expression of 'man over plant' while at the same time demonstrating 'man understands plants'...and will put the amount of time necessary to keep them happy and thriving. You must have asked the OP to send pictures. It would be nice to see if his plant would be a good candidate for this style. – stormy Sep 25 '14 at 21:32

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.